🚚 Feedback needed: Drag and Drop blocks in rich text fields and documents

Handles can show on-mouseover (particularly if the area is targeted to only near the left, outside the text area slightly) which makes them discoverable but not overwhelming. Discoverability is critical to getting any adoption of this feature and therefore making it worth maintaining or even improving.

Personally I find the current implementation novel but clunky. It’s difficult - if not impossible - to get it to treat dropping of blocks into indented areas correctly, for example. Because it has not been reliable I simply don’t use it, too much frustration. It’s one of those things that kind of needs to work really well, or not at all, and in that sense the barrier to implementation and adoption is high :smile: Notion is essentially the gold standard here.

That said I am glad to see this being experimented with! A lot of people still really love and want block-based editing. I hope a good implementation can be arrived at without too much further effort. You might take a read through this for some ideas…

2 Likes

I’m a heavy user of ordered and unordered lists and have spent most of this week copying bullet points into Notion/Coda to rearrange and then back into Fibery :pensive:
Are there any plans to continue improvements here? Working with anything below the first tier of a list is still quite challenging.

5 Likes

Oh yes, please. That is one of the few main pain points I have limiting efficiency in Fibery, along with lacking keyboard shortcuts.
On the point of efficiency, I strongly suggest having a look at how Superhuman have solved shortcuts etc

1 Like

I do the same thing but in Tana :sweat_smile:

1 Like

@helloitse @Sarah_Arminta Could you record shot video in Notion and Tana and post here how it works for you?

3 Likes

5 Likes

Forgot you can also do multiples at once:

5 Likes

As a Ipad user, With keyboard only, I dont want to use mouse option. Just moving lines by hotkey, example Ctrl + Shift + up/down like obsidian

I feel like this was never fully completed.

Got feedback from a client that they found it weird that views have the drag and drop handles in rich text field, but everything else doesn’t. They migrated from notion.

I shared with them that they can press escape, but it’s indeed something that’s quite hard to find.

3 Likes

It would be nice if you could use the arrow keys once a block is selected to move up and down one position.

1 Like

Yes, the current state is fairly janky. Especially in certain contexts like lists. Dragging an item in a list to another place just… sucks.

1 Like

Yes, drag and drop for blocks behavior isn’t fully implemented yet, but we’re working on an update :hugs:

4 Likes

I have done the same.

Successive Esc doesn’t extend to the heading. I would like to be able to move an entire Heading group.

3 Likes